top of page

JOIN OUR EMAIL LIST

Be the first to know when we publish our next blog or book, launch our podcast, or have other updates and announcements.

The Professional Cost of Being a Mandated Reporter

11 minutes ago
4 min read

By Kathryn S. Krase, PhD JD MSW

A project of Krase Consulting


Part 4 in a series


Introduction to Our Research


Mandated reporters are people required to make reports to child protective services (CPS) in their given state. We read and hear a lot about what mandated reporters are supposed to do and when. What we read and hear about far less is what mandated reporters actually think about the policy of mandated reporting, the system that reports are made into, and how the role of mandated reporter actually impacts the reporter, personally and professionally. 


Interest in learning more about the experiences of mandated reporters was the starting point for a study I conducted with three colleagues — Dr. Latoya Attis, Dr. Emily Murphy, and Michelle Desir, LCSW. We surveyed nearly 400 mandated reporters across the country: mental health professionals, medical providers, educators, social service workers, child welfare staff, and more. The findings related to the opinions of mandated reporters was the subject of our first research article currently under peer review with Children and Youth Services Review. 


The first three posts in this series looked at confidence in the system — whether reporters believe mandated reporting is good policy, and whether they believe CPS actually protects children and helps families. This post turns to a different question: what does carrying the mandated reporter role cost the professional?

The clearest divide in the study

51.0% of the mandated reporters we surveyed agreed or strongly agreed that being a mandated reporter complicates their relationships with clients; 33.9% disagreed. On its own, 51% a striking number — just over half of professionals report that the role itself creates friction in the relationships that are supposed to be the vehicle for their help. But what made this item stand out wasn't the topline number. It was how sharply it split by profession — the clearest professional-group divide of anything we measured in the entire study.


Medical professionals were significantly less likely to feel the role complicates their client relationships. Mental health professionals were significantly more likely to feel it does. That gap makes intuitive sense once you think about what each relationship is built on: a physical exam is a different kind of relationship than an ongoing therapeutic alliance built on trust and disclosure. The reporting mandate lands very differently depending on what kind of relationship it's cutting across.

The same motivation, the opposite effect

In Post 2, we found that reporters motivated by legal obligation were less supportive of mandated reporting as policy, while reporters motivated by concern for the child were more supportive. The same two motivations show up here — and they point in the same directions, but for a different outcome:


  • Reporters who cited legal obligation as their reason for reporting were considerably more likely to feel the role complicates their client relationships — one of the largest effects in the entire study.

  • Reporters who cited concern for the child were considerably less likely to feel that strain.


Put Post 2 and this post side by side and a pattern emerges: 

  • Reporting out of fear of personal legal consequences is associated with less faith in the policy and more felt cost to the professional relationship. 

  • Reporting out of concern for the child is associated with more faith in the policy and less felt cost. 

Same motivation, tracked across two different outcomes, same direction both times.


Knowledge matters, again

Throughout this series, knowing more about how the CPS system actually functions — the real substantiation rate, the racial disparities in reporting — has consistently predicted less confidence that the system works. Here, that same knowledge predicts more perceived relational complication. Reporters who understood these realities were more likely to say the mandated reporter role creates friction with clients. It's the same underlying skepticism, just showing up as a different kind of cost: not "I don't think this helps," but "I think this makes my job with this person harder."


What holds up in the full model

Once everything else was accounted for in the multivariate analysis, a few things remained independently significant: older reporters and those more satisfied with their training reported less perceived complication; reporters with more education, and those who said they'd considered other ways to support a family before reporting, reported more professional complication. And the professional-role finding held firm — being a mental health professional independently predicted more perceived relational complication, even controlling for training, knowledge, demographics, and experience together.


Among reporters specifically, the legal-obligation effect didn't just survive — it strengthened. Controlling for everything else, framing a report as a matter of legal duty was independently associated with greater perceived damage to the client relationship.


What this points to

If you supervise or train mandated reporters, this post and the last one are really describing the same coin from two sides. Reporting out of fear of the law, rather than out of belief in what reporting accomplishes, doesn't just correlate with lower faith in the system — it correlates with a harder-felt cost to the relationships professionals are trying to sustain. That's a heavier burden to carry, and it's carried disproportionately by the people whose work depends most on relational trust.


Feeling like the role complicates a relationship is one kind of weight. A more personal kind of weight — plain fear, either of a parent's reaction or of your own legal exposure — is a separate question, and it turns out to behave differently from everything we've covered so far. That's next.





This research is co-authored with Dr. Latoya Attis (Wurzweiler School of Social Work, Yeshiva University), Dr. Emily Murphy (School of Social and Behavioral Sciences, Mercy University), and Michelle Desir, LCSW (Silbermann School of Social Work, Hunter College). A preprint of our research study is available on SSRN; the paper is currently under peer review at Children and Youth Services Review, and findings discussed in this series should be considered preliminary until publication. his research was supported by Children's Rights, Inc.


If this research resonates with you, consider learning more about the New York Mandated Reporting Working Group — a coalition of advocates, professionals, and impacted individuals — working towards a trust-based approach to service to children and families that better supports families and strengthens their stability and well-being. Learn more at https://www.nymrwg.org/ 



Cite this blog: 

Krase, K. (2026, November 18). The professional cost of being a mandated reporter. Krase Consulting Blog.


Comments


JOIN OUR EMAIL LIST

Be the first to know when we publish our next blog or book, launch our podcast, or have other updates and announcements.

bottom of page